Skip to content

Why Are You Reading Reviews About Black Panther When You Could Be Watching Black Panther?

38
Share

Why Are You Reading Reviews About Black Panther When You Could Be Watching Black Panther?

Home / Why Are You Reading Reviews About Black Panther When You Could Be Watching Black Panther?
Movies & TV movie reviews

Why Are You Reading Reviews About Black Panther When You Could Be Watching Black Panther?

By

Published on February 16, 2018

38
Share
Black Panther, 2018

Do you really need anyone to tell you that you should go see Black Panther? Do you?

You are reading these words, so maybe you do. So I’ll do my best here.

[This is a non-spoiler review of the film.]

Words kind of fail me, though, so I’ll start with similes and see where we end up…

Black Panther is like heading to a feast and finding that every food on the table is one of your favorite dishes, so you cry because you’re not sure how you’ll ever eat with that many possibilities and limited stomach space?

Black Panther is like reading a book and then being furious when it’s over because you can never read it for the first time again.

Black Panther is like realizing that you’ve spent your life rolling around in a dumpster because you just rolled around in gold leaf and puppies for the first time and it was awesome.

Black Panther is like the first time you ever watched Star Wars or Fellowship of the Ring; your brain starts behaving like it’s high because the whole experience feels like a dreamscape you’ve been desperately reaching for in your waking hours.

Black Panther is what I imagine a benevolent hurricane to be like, if those existed.

And this is pretty much just a fringe response because this movie isn’t even for me. Sure, I’m part of some checkbox demographic for being a geek who loves superheroes and all that. But when I left the theater, there was a crowd of black filmgoers taking pictures in front of the cardboard cutout of T’Challa, arms crossed over their chests like Wakandans, and it felt like my heart was going to explode. This movie belongs to them. That’s really all that matters.

Black Panther

If you want a little more than that to shore you up until you’re in the theater, here’s what I’ve got. Both Ludwig Göransson’s score and Kendrick Lamar’s album for the film are transcendental. While Marvel films have floundered a bit in musical unity and power over the past decade, this is one soundtrack that will stand up in the years and decades to come. The costume work blows everything else out of the water in functionality, use of color, and imagination. The design work is unified and immaculate, which will offer a wonderful new layer to the MCU in movies to come.

The action sequences are all gems, tucked away and ready to burst. From the trailers they seemed kind of rote, flashy but nothing you haven’t seen before. The context of the fights make all the difference, and all the best reveals were helpfully withheld. If you like innovative action (especially action that isn’t over-reliant on guns), this movie is what your looking for. It seamlessly blends genres via the weaponry, choreography, and geography; some of the action has an Afropunk/Matrix vibe, some of it renders epic fantasy melded with Afrofuturism.

If I could make any critique whatsoever (aside from a super pedantic complaint that Wakadan letters match up with English ones whenever place name flashes on the screen), it would be that the plot itself is relatively predictable—but it’s barely a weakness, as the film occupies a space that is meant to play with superhero narratives and old epic structures. You could call it Shakespearean, you could call it mythic, but that’s not where the film lives. It’s not about the broad strokes, it’s about the details. It’s about all the little choices in concert, creating something brand new, and creating it on a scale that cinema has never seen before.

Black Panther, 2018

The cast is perfection. Chadwick Boseman radiates grace as T’Challa, even in his most conflicted moments. Michael B. Jordan’s Killmonger is the kind of villain that always works best in these films; not only one who has a personal beef to hash out with the hero, but one who is fighting for the right reasons via the wrong means. (Jordan himself has compared their dynamic to Professor X and Magneto, and it’s an extremely apt comparison to make.) Martin Freeman’s CIA operative Everett K. Ross, while largely ineffectual in his introduction in Captain America: Civil War, is ironically amusing as all get-out in this context, mostly just dragged about and constantly hushed.

The women in this film are phenomenal. Much deserved love for T’Challa aside, it is almost hard to care about him between the likes of his mother Ramonda (Angela Bassett), his sister Shuri (Letitia Wright), his general Okoye (Danai Gurira), and his ex-lover-turned-spy Nakia (Lupita Nyong’o) around. Every single one of these women is unique, every single one of them has incredible strength and brilliance. Black Panther has single-handedly knocked the entire MCU off its axis in its depiction of female characters. There are so many of them in one place for the very first time in any of these movies, and they are never sidelined by the story to make T’Challa more impressive—because the film understands that being surrounded by and listening to these women is what makes him impressive.

Black Panther women

Seriously. Black Widow and Peggy Carter and Pepper Potts are all so important and wonderful, but I would willing go into battle and die if Okoye told me to. I would test every one of Shuri’s technological experiments, regardless of safety factors. I would wait on Queen Ramonda and I would travel the world undercover with Nakia. Any day, any time or place. And what’s better, these women are never objectified sexually or performatively, and none of them are put into gender normative boxes. They each have their own skills, their own clear perspectives, and they are all essential to the story.

Could have done with more Ramonda, though…

The film hits political notes that resonate deeply through the world right now, for all peoples and nations. Wakanda, as we know from Civil War, has hidden its advancements away from the world, keeping prying eyes at bay and warding off colonists who would raid their country for its resources. But such secrecy means that Wakanda has primarily looked after its own for millennia. With the world beginning to catch up to them, with people in need of help, and more threats cropping up every day, T’Challa and his people have a choice to make; do they continue to keep to themselves, or do they abandon those pretenses and help those who would greatly benefit from their wisdom and guidance?

It’s a refreshing tack to take, refusing to make the MCU so different from our own world that it ignores the effects of imperialism and disenfranchisement. The themes of the film sharply call out isolationist thinking, making the case for banding together and treating each other as a unified people, but it does so without sidelining the effects of colonization, mass incarceration, and poverty. It makes Wakanda and all of its riches—technologically and culturally—the inheritance of black people around the world.

Black Panther, 2018

Do not cheat yourself out of this experience. Take your friends and your loved ones and soak in the vision that is Wakanda. Repeat the process as often as needed. It can only make the world brighter.

(And then come back next week for spoilery thoughts from Alex Brown!)

Emmet Asher-Perrin sobbed so hard through the last half hour of this film that she gave herself a migraine. You can bug her on Twitter and Tumblr, and read more of her work here and elsewhere.

About the Author

Emmet Asher-Perrin

Author

Emmet Asher-Perrin is the News & Entertainment Editor of Reactor. Their words can also be perused in tomes like Queers Dig Time Lords, Lost Transmissions: The Secret History of Science Fiction and Fantasy, and Uneven Futures: Strategies for Community Survival from Speculative Fiction. They cannot ride a bike or bend their wrists. You can find them on Bluesky and other social media platforms where they are mostly quiet because they'd rather talk to you face-to-face.
Learn More About Emmet
Subscribe
Notify of
Avatar


38 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Avatar
7 years ago

Why Are You Reading Reviews About Black Panther When You Could Be Watching Black Panther?

Because I’m too old and cranky to deal with opening-weekend crowds…

Avatar
7 years ago

Why Are You Reading Reviews About Black Panther When You Could Be Watching Black Panther?

Because I’m too old to go to midnight sneak peak showings and I have this “work” think I do on weekdays.  Unless it’s sold out, I will be watching it this weekend.

Avatar
7 years ago

Because I have to work and I can read this at work.  Going to see it next week when I can get out early.

Avatar
7 years ago

           Why Are You Reading Reviews About Black Panther When You Could Be Watching Black Panther?

 

I’d love to see it. Do you have the money for the ticket? Poor pay & not enough hours says I don’t so I watch via the reviews instead. 

Avatar
houndie
7 years ago

Because the local cinema is waiting till the 23th, as far as I know.

Avatar
7 years ago

I saw it last night and agree! The costumes, the music, the acting, all the strong women! I absolutely loved the General.

Also – for folks with a large movie chain nearby, many are now doing Thursday night screenings at 7-8pm in addition to the ‘midnight’ showing.

It’s the best movie-going non-secret my friends and I have. We’ve seen the last couple Marvel movies, and the last 3 Star Wars this way. 

(Plus I’m getting too old for midnight showings… I like sleep more now.)

krad
7 years ago

Because I’m at a convention and my wife is at a different convention, so we’re going to see it Monday night when we’re both back home. :)

—Keith R.A. DeCandido

 

Sunspear
7 years ago

Because I offered my girlfriend dinner and a movie for Valentine’s. When I said Black panther, she said, “But that’s what you want to see!”

She’s a Marvel fan, but she gets fidgety sitting in a theater. Plus it’s flu season and there’s lotsa people walking around not covering their coughs… 

Still holding out hope.

Avatar
Kate
7 years ago

Because I want to know if it lives up to the hype.

Because the seats available this weekend suck.

Because I hate sitting right next to anyone in a theater except for my honey so I’ll wait until it’s more empty, like maybe a midweek matinee.

 

 

 

Avatar
7 years ago

It was really, really good. Letitia Wright’s Shuri was my favorite. A close second was Winston Duke as M’Baku. Chadwick Boseman did a great job, as did Michael B. Jordan. Killmonger was a good antagonist, not just a cookie cutter villain, with believable motivations. Martin Freeman is getting really good at playing the guy that gets dragged along on other people’s adventures: Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy, Hobbit, Sherlock and now Black Panther.

Avatar
7 years ago

Because I just came back from watching it! Godsdamn this was a fantastice watch

The set and clothing designers for this need to win all the awards. If there’s any justice, this will kickstart some other mass-market Afrofuturist works (Zelazny! Jemisin! Monae!)

The acting in this is also sooooo good. Particular shout-out to Michael B Jordan – who’s the most thought-out Marvel villain since Zemo, Winston Duke – who makes M’Baku work!, and Letitia Wright, who’s a joy whenever she’s on screen. Everyone was great in it though (except Daniel Kaluuya and Forest Whitaker – they both seemed to sleepwalk through the roles)

I’m with EA-P – Watch this nowwwww!

Sunspear
7 years ago

@11. snowcrash: ” the most thought-out Marvel villain since Zemo”

Do you mean the MCU Zemo or comics version? Cause for me he was very underwhelming.

lumineaux
lumineaux
7 years ago

Because all of the shows at my local theaters are sold out until some time next week.

Avatar
7 years ago

@@@@@12. Sunspear

MCU Zemo – I found his plotting and reasoning to be among the better ones by the MCU villains (other than Killmonger and him, the only ones I’m fond of would be Vulture and Loki. I also have a soft spot for Trevor, but that’s just me)

Avatar
7 years ago

Because I watched last night. It wasn’t mind-blowing plot-wise, but it was very good, it was awesome visually and thematically, and I agree with almost everything you say on the review.

Also, I’m heterosexual, but I think Michael B. Jordan’s Killmonger is sexy AF.

Avatar
Brendaa
7 years ago

I have a question – does this make sense as a stand-alone film? I’ve seen all the previous Marvel movies but my dad has not, and I know he’s interested. Will it be confusing to him? How much would I need to explain going in?

Avatar
7 years ago

@16. Brendaa 

I’d say this one is pretty standalone. There’s a flashback regarding the major Black Panther-related event in Civil War, and the rest is mostly self-contained.

Avatar
7 years ago

Totally stand-alone.

Bayushi
Bayushi
7 years ago

EVERYTHING you said about this movie is how I felt about it!  My roommate is running around genuinely wanting a “Wakanda Forever!” tee, we’re both in love with the soundtrack, and just…this is truly an amazing movie.  I loved it with every fiber of my being.

Avatar
zegmustprovebrains
7 years ago

And no-one has even mentioned the armoured attack rhinoceros!

There’s a lot to love about this film–the characters, the action sequences–but the charging rhinos with the big slobbery tongues are what really won my heart.

Avatar
7 years ago

Dude, spoilers. That might be a minor thing, but this is specifically a no spoiler reward.

Sunspear
7 years ago

Ran across this in looking at Panther related stuff today:

Janelle Monae’s Dirty Computer

I like her as a performer and the teaser features Ragnarok’s Valkyrie.

Avatar
7 years ago

As noted, this is a spoiler-free zone! Everyone has different ideas about spoilers, so please feel free to cautiously white-out any text that’s about specific details of the film. Thank you!

Avatar
7 years ago

Because, like in houndie’s case, it would not be here before the 23rd :(
Oh, man. I’ve been sold to the Marvel ones from the moment I first laid my eyes on Tony, and they have never disappointed me, so I was already confident I’m gonna love it, but after reading this, I’m even more excited than I already was … Oh, actually, thanks a lot. Now I want to see it NOW. And it’s still a week away for me.

Avatar
7 years ago

Because movie theaters are a sensory nightmare – far too loud, the screen too big and overwhelming, and you can’t pause and walk away if you get overwhelmed.  

Give me a theater with a half-size screen and where I can control the volume (and, in particular, turn down background noise and sound effects while keeping voices louder) and I’d maybe consider it.  

Avatar
7 years ago

Because we have two young kids who were baaaarely able to sit through the latest Star Wars movie and don’t want to pay for a sitter (I love how everybody is seriously answering the question, lol).

But your review has made me SUPER pumped to get it once it’s available for rental :)

Sunspear
7 years ago

Another site had a review header; “We watched it so you don’t have to.”

I was like, “Get the hell outa here with your smug selves!”

Avatar
gwangung
7 years ago

A minor amazing point is that this films turned an ex Air Force pilot and current CIA agent into the thematic equivalent of the Christopher Priest original version. That’s just amazing.

Avatar
7 years ago

Yes, I liked that. It was only missing him declaring himself “King of the White Boys”.

Avatar
gwangung
7 years ago

29: Think I would have totally died if they had worked that phrase into the movie…. (would have matched the couple dozen other deths I did, I think….)

Avatar
7 years ago

I did utter it aloud at one point….

Avatar

Took my two sons to this yesterday afternoon and we all loved it – “Six thumbs up!”

Gorgeous soundtrack (definitely going to be the favorite for the Oscar), cinematography, fight scenes, & casting.

I liked everyone and thought they were fabulous.

Loved the two “Tolkien White Guys,” the current internet pun goes, and felt they added to the movie as well.

The backstory, however, really impressed me.  I don’t know much of the comic version of Black Panther – I was more of a mutant comic Marvel fan than Avengers/FF comics.  So for them to truly bring to life Wakanda for me was amazing.  They really made it a comic book futuristic nation.

Finally, on a far more selfish note, I hope this movie will be a challenge to all the comic movies that follow it.  Black Panther should now be the standard that all writers & directors should aspire to match and even surpass.

I cannot wait for the extended cut dvd movie box set (& Black Panther II).  With 5 hours cut down to 2:15 hrs (approximately) I am sure there will be lots to see.  

Kato

PS – @@@@@ 20zegmustprovebrains & 21MaGnUs, loved that part as well.

Avatar
7 years ago

Every time I see a “comment removed,” I wonder to what idiotic depths of trollery somebody had to go to to manage to get their comment erased.  

I’ve not watched this movie — I’m not a fan of action movies, in general, or super-hero movies, in particular, but I’m a real anti-fan of current movie theatres, which I tend to leave with headaches from the overly loud sound and hideously intrusive ads.

That said, this movie does sound awesome, and it also sounds like it passes the Bechtel test.  It also seems to have skittered past the Hollywood executives without whitewashing and turning all the female characters into semi-nude eye candy.  When it hits on-demand, I’ll give it a try.

Sunspear
7 years ago

Scale is the only thing movie theaters have left going for them. We used to go frequently. Now it’s maybe twice a year for movies like this, where I’d rather not wait. You can own a copy later for the price of one ticket now. That’s a strange business model. When more people wake up to that, the theater business will crash.

Not to mention that there’s twenty minutes of commercials even though you pay upfront. The sound is often untuned, blaring. And I get a better picture and resolution on my widescreen TV at home.

Avatar
7 years ago

I know its just a movie.  but the premise is this is a high tech/advance country that some how avoid being exploited & colonize.  Do they explain this and do the other African nations resent them for not getting involved and preventing it happening to them? Just curious.

Avatar
7 years ago

@37, To be fair to Wakandans pre colonial African nations were no more likely to be friendly and cooperative with each other than contemporary European nations. The isolation probably started to protect themselves from other Africans. I suppose they deserve some credit for not becoming an imperialist state themselves given their advantage.. Maybe.

Avatar
Priya
7 years ago

Black Panther is one of the few Marvel films that sets up a character while being a spectacle to view from start to finish. I would say the first Iron Man film is the last time we had a testament to origin stories that also keeps the viewers attention as an entertaining movie.

Avatar
Mark
6 years ago

I’m black and Im NOT from WAKANDA . The Black panther movie was stupid and from a media point of view the movie written by Ryan Gogler only made box offices because of its ethnic features. It does not in any way HONOR African Americans that fought for their civil rights or represent the black movement it is simply just a MOVIE.